I live in hopeWhat price Jewish brotherhood?

A time to lower the temperature

There needs to be dialogue and a willingness to listen. On both sides.

Police detain an ultra-Orthodox man during a protest against Charedi enlistment outside a military recruitment center in Jerusalem, November 12, 2025. Photo: Chaim Goldberg/Flash90
Police detain an ultra-Orthodox man during a protest against Charedi enlistment outside a military recruitment center in Jerusalem, November 12, 2025. Photo: Chaim Goldberg/Flash90

What price Jewish brotherhood?

It was a rare commodity at the quinquennial WZC which I attended last month as a delegate. And it is scarcely visible amid the ongoing Charedi draft debate, an issue which I would like to address here from both sides of the divide.

There needs to be a drastic lowering of the temperature, a willingness of each side to understand where the other is coming from and to compromise.

It does not help when chiloni (secular) activists call yeshivah students “parasites feeding off the state”. It is utterly beyond the pale when a prominent chiloni declares, “Charedim who refuse to serve don’t deserve to live!”

But it is also indefensible when a Charedi radical declares, “I would rather die than serve in the IDF!” and when Charedi spokesmen provocatively declare “It’s the yeshivahs, not the IDF, that is keeping Israel safe.”

You have reached your monthly article limit

You have reached your monthly limit of 3 articles. Do you want to keep reading The Australian Jewish News? Subscribe Now
read more:
comments

Enjoy Unlimited Access To The Australian Jewish News Website And All Our Online Content For AUD$18/month Or Just AUD$120/year.

Subscribe Now