Kotel and Jewish unityThe Kotel's dangerous turn toward exclusion

What happens after the dream comes true?

As debate over the Kotel grows, Rabbi Yonatan Sadoff reflects on belonging, unity and Jewish peoplehood.

Conservative rabbis at the egalitarian prayer space at the Western Wall in 2024. 
Photo: Courtesy/File
Conservative rabbis at the egalitarian prayer space at the Western Wall in 2024. Photo: Courtesy/File

In September 11, 2001, I was supposed to board a plane to Israel. The world changed that day, and I remained in New York through those weeks, eventually arriving in Jerusalem just before Yom Kippur. On Yom Kippur night, my new flatmate and I walked together to the Kotel.

Sitting outside the prayer plaza, he turned to me and said something I have never forgotten.

“Intellectually,” he told me, “I don’t even know why this wall should matter to me. I don’t long for a Third Temple. I believe God is everywhere, not in one place. Rationally, I don’t understand why this place should hold such power.”

Then he paused.

“But every time I walk up to those stones, press my face against them, and begin to pray, I start crying uncontrollably. My heart and soul just don’t seem to understand what my intellect is telling them.”

You have reached your monthly article limit

You have reached your monthly limit of 3 articles. Do you want to keep reading The Australian Jewish News? Subscribe Now
read more:
comments

Enjoy Unlimited Access To The Australian Jewish News Website And All Our Online Content For AUD$18/month Or Just AUD$120/year.

Subscribe Now