Hostages in Gaza

600: A Horrible Milestone

Six hundred days on, 58 hostages remain in Gaza. A reflection on what Western equivocation over their captivity says about the civilisation that allows it.

A man walks past images of those held in Gaza at Hostage Square in Tel Aviv on January 19, 2025 Photo: Miriam Alster/FLASH90

On 28 May 2025, the world marked a grim and shameful milestone—600 days since the October 7 massacre. And still, 58 hostages remain in the hands of Hamas. Among them are women, elderly civilians, young people abducted from a music festival, and the bodies of the dead. Their continued captivity—and the silence, moral confusion, or outright equivocation of much of the international community—is an indictment not only of failed political leadership, but of the moral direction of the Western world itself.

This is not a Jewish tragedy alone. It is a Western one. Because what we choose to tolerate, we eventually become.

The Geneva Conventions—cornerstones of civilised warfare—are unambiguous: the taking of hostages is strictly prohibited. Article 3, common to all four conventions, forbids “violence to life and person,” including murder, torture, and “the taking of hostages.” These are not technicalities or cultural preferences. They are universal principles, written in the blood of the 20th century. That they are now routinely flouted by a terrorist organisation that openly declares its genocidal intent should provoke widespread outrage. Instead, too many Western governments have chosen appeasement, abstraction—or worse, moral relativism masquerading as nuance.

In Judaism, the sanctity of life is paramount—and so too is the dignity of the dead. The refusal to return the bodies of hostages is not a political ploy; it is a deliberate psychological torment, designed to prolong suffering, prevent closure, and weaponize grief. It is cruel. It is calculated. And it works—because we care. Because civilised societies care.

We’ve seen this script before.

In June 2006, Corporal Gilad Shalit was kidnapped by Hamas in a cross-border raid near the Kerem Shalom crossing—an attack that, for comparison, would be akin to an ADF Reserve soldier being abducted by insurgents while on peacekeeping duties in a Pacific island nation. Shalit was just 19 years old. He was held in Gaza for over five years, in isolation, without access to the Red Cross or outside communication. In 2011, Israel agreed to a painful exchange: 1,027 Palestinian prisoners in return for Shalit’s freedom. Among them was Yahya Sinwar, a founding member of Hamas’ military wing—one of the chief architects of the October 7 massacre.

That exchange, driven by humanitarian instinct, should have served as a cautionary tale. Instead, it became a blueprint—a signal to terrorists that Western empathy and Israeli humanity can be weaponised.

The hostage enterprise functions because it is effective. It preys on the very values that underpin democratic civilisation. But when that moral framework is manipulated—and when that manipulation is rewarded by naïve, compromised, or cowardly leaders—we don’t just embolden terrorists. We betray our own values.

The Western world must now confront a hard truth: who benefits when we pressure Israel to show restraint? Who gains when calls for “proportionality” echo louder than the cries of those still buried in tunnels beneath Gaza, denied light, freedom, and hope?

Terrorists understand the West better than many Westerners do. They know exactly which buttons to push—how to prompt a UN resolution, dominate a news cycle, or stir outrage on university campuses. They speak our language—”resistance,” “colonialism,” “decolonisation”—not because they believe it, but because they know we do. And they have no qualms about holding hostages in children’s bedrooms or stockpiling weapons in hospitals.

And yet, under impossible pressure, Israel’s democratically elected government has shown moral clarity and resolve. While Israel’s enemies use civilians as shields and corpses as currency, Jerusalem has upheld its duty to protect its people and recover its citizens—despite a global chorus of weak-willed, posturing statements from leaders more concerned with social sentiment than security.

To those leaders I say: history will not be kind. Your timidity in the face of barbarism—your moral posturing while families mourn without graves—will not be remembered as diplomacy, but as dereliction.

We are witnessing not merely a war for territory, but a war for truth itself. And the truth is this:

Israel did not start this war. Hamas did.

Israel does not target civilians. Hamas does.

Israel values life. Hamas glorifies death.

To argue otherwise is to invert morality.

As Israeli statesman Abba Eban once remarked, “History teaches us that men and nations behave wisely once they have exhausted all other alternatives.” Let us pray we do not exhaust our conscience before then.

And as Golda Meir so powerfully observed, “We will only have peace with the Arabs when they love their children more than they hate us.”

Until that day, let the world mark this horrible milestone:

600 days. Fifty-eight hostages. Countless shattered families.

And a Western world at the crossroads—forced to decide, yet again, whether it still stands for anything at all.

Colonel Michael Scott CSC Ret’d is a former Australian army officer and the founder of The 2023 Foundation, an initiative dedicated to combating antisemitism.

read more: