ZFA keynote interview

Bret Stephens: Antisemitism is ‘not a Jewish problem’

New York Times columnist says anti-Jewish hate is a problem for the societies that incubate antisemitism; urges Australian Jews to be ’10 per cent Jewier’

Bret Stephens at the ZFA Biennial Conference.

Antisemitism is “not a Jewish problem” but a problem for the societies that incubate it, The New York Times columnist Bret Stephens has told the Zionist Federation of Australia (ZFA) Biennial Conference.

In conversation with ZFA director of public affairs and strategy Lisa Mittelman on November 22, Stephens was challenged on his argument, made in a speech in New York in February, that Jewish communities devote too much energy to fighting antisemitism.

He said he was not suggesting communities neglect security, which he called “essential”.

“But antisemitism, this is a point I return to again and again, is not a Jewish problem,” he said. “It’s a problem for antisemites, and it’s a problem for the societies that incubate antisemitism, because there is not a society in history that, after having been infected past a critical point with antisemitism, hasn’t gone down the drain.

“Don’t place too many hopes on this. Antisemitism is incurable … It’s not an educational problem. You cannot have rational arguments with irrational people, and you cannot reason people out of the resentment and envy which is the basis of antisemitism.”

Stephens, who is also editor-in-chief of the Jewish quarterly Sapir, said that in an interview earlier in his visit he had been asked how much Australian education should focus on the Holocaust or antisemitism.

“Honestly, zero, right? Or a little bit,” he said. “But the main thing that young non-Jewish Australians should know is that they could not have an Australia with the values that it has if the Jews 3000 years ago hadn’t started to articulate these values in a profound and true way. If they got that, then everything else will fall.”

He listed those values as freedom, the ethical universalism that accompanies monotheism, and “inscribing the dissenting view inside the tradition, rather than treating dissent as heresy”, which he described as central to democracy.

Stephens said Australia had a role to play. “Australia is … an important pillar in a united fight by what I would still call the West against the enemies of freedom, and the enemies of freedom are uniting, and they are willful and they are capable, whether they’re Beijing or Tehran or Moscow or Pyongyang,” he said.

“What we’re now seeing is a return to the same situation we had in the 1930s, where the bad guys are not just colluding, they’re openly cooperating, and the West is divided and fractious and doesn’t understand what it’s about.”

He said the Jews were “Australia’s most essential ally in understanding what it might have to fight for if it’s going to survive as a free and independent commonwealth”.

Stephens explained how his phrase “the October 8 Jew”, coined after seeing celebrations at a protest in New York’s Times Square the day after the Hamas attack, had evolved. He said the protesters, at a rally organised by a Democratic Socialists-affiliated group, wore “a look of ecstasy”.

“I thought this is the happiest day of their lives. 1200 Jews have just been slaughtered, and they’re not worried about what’s going to happen next. They’re just happy,” he said. “They’re on Team Hamas.”

Bret Stephens (left) talks with Lisa Mittelman.

He said October 8 also exposed university and institutional leaders who had been outspoken after the murder of George Floyd, but “became oddly quiet when 1200 Jews were being murdered”.

He initially wrote that it was the day American Jews learned “who our friends are not”. On reflection, he said, it became the day “so many Jews began to ask themselves, ‘Who am I really? What does it really mean for me to be a Jew?'”

“What is going to define us as Jews is not the kind of Jew our grandfather was in Poland or anywhere else. It’s the kind of Jew our grandchild is going to be in Sydney or anywhere else,” he said.

He urged the community to become “10 per cent Jewier”, a play on the book 10% Happier.

“Ask yourself not only in your personal lives but especially in your communal lives, how can you up the Jewiness 10 per cent, so that it’s not a life-changing demand, but it’s enough to get its hooks into you,” he said. “Every Jewish institution needs to kind of have a Chabad mentality … which is to say, it’s happy with what it can get.”

Asked whether it was worth engaging with antizionist Jews, Stephens said the Jewish tent should be broad, “but it’s not an infinite tent”. He said that included making room for left-wing Zionists whose views others might abhor, noting that the next issue of Sapir would carry an essay from “someone who’s like on a very left edge of that tent”.

“They’re in our family, and there is nothing wrong with powerful criticism of the policies of the state of Israel,” he said. “We’re not Jews unless we’re arguing.”

But antizionism, he said, was “a direct threat to the life, liberty, and sovereignty of the majority of the world’s Jews”.

“People call them self-hating Jews. That is a mistake. These people love themselves. They’re the most narcissistic people.”

He said Jewish education was “the surest way of creating proud Jews”, and praised students he had met at Mount Scopus Memorial College and Moriah College.

read more: