Candidates pressed on Roberts, Islamic Council
Caulfield's One Nation candidate unaware of Roberts' Bondi remarks; Labor candidate questions ICV head
One Nation’s candidate for Caulfield told a Jewish community forum on Thursday night that he was not familiar with Senator Malcolm Roberts’ refusal to rule out that the Bondi massacre was a “false flag” operation.
Labor’s candidate, meanwhile, said she wondered whether the president of the Islamic Council of Victoria (ICV) was “appropriate for that role”.
Michael Abelman (One Nation), Mikaela Stafrace (Labor) and sitting Liberal MP and deputy leader David Southwick took questions at a Jewish Community Council of Victoria and Zionism Victoria forum at Beth Weizmann Community Centre, nine days before the November 28 state election.
The evening was conducted civilly, with the audience letting each candidate have their say.
Abelman, who is Jewish, was asked whether he was comfortable representing One Nation given concerns about antisemitism among some party figures and supporters, and about Roberts’ comments.
“I’ve got to say that I’m not familiar with Malcolm saying it’s a false flag event. Apologies, I haven’t heard that before,” he said.
The moderator then read out Roberts’ published words: “I don’t have the facts yet. I’m not ruling it out.” Abelman said it was “very sensible” not to comment without the facts. In a July opinion piece, Roberts wrote that he did not think the massacre was a false flag.
Abelman said claims that One Nation was antisemitic or racist were “false” and blamed media coverage. He pointed to the party’s swift disendorsement of its Preston candidate Franco Guardiani over posts that appeared to praise Hitler.
Asked by audience member Ron Saunders why One Nation’s treatment of Muslims would not one day be directed at Jews, Abelman agreed racism against any community was a risk to Jews, but added: “Jews don’t blow things up as much as Muslims do. So when you’re talking about Islamophobia, it’s not an irrational fear.”
He said Muslims not involved in extremism should not be targeted.
On antisemitism, he said no new laws were needed, only a change in the directions the government gives police. On cost of living, he named cheaper energy through “reliable power” as the most important measure.
Stafrace was asked why Labor was proposing to involve the ICV in its $3 million anti-Islamophobia initiative, given reports that ICV president Mohamed Mohideen had shared antisemitic posts depicting Jews as devils with horns.
“He’s a very different kettle of fish, and the first thing is that I wonder whether he’s appropriate for that role,” she said.
But she argued the council should not be punished for its leader. “If that sort of thing goes on, don’t blame the entire group and say you get no money. Look at your governance, and if that’s something on our party, on our government, then we fix it.”
Pressed further, she said: “The president is the issue. It’s not the council … If that’s the kind of behaviour that goes on, then get them off.”
On antisemitism, Stafrace said Jewish Australians should “never, ever” have to apologise for what happens in a foreign country, and cited Labor’s antisemitism education taskforce, mandatory Holocaust education in Years 9 and 10, and the adoption of the IHRA definition. On cost of living, she pointed to free public transport for under-18s and free kindergarten.
She also addressed the Caulfield ALP branch’s rejection in March of a motion opposing BDS, saying she was not then the endorsed candidate and was not registered to vote in the branch.
Southwick, who the moderator noted had served as deputy to three Liberal leaders in four years, was asked whether his team was united and stable. He conceded the party had struggled at state level, but said that under Jess Wilson, MPs were “working united, like I’ve never seen”.
On antisemitism, he said the government had funded agencies employing people who posted antisemitic material. “The Victorian Multicultural Commission had a chair who was very much in the forefront of all of this, and what we saw was a review … No action taken, and that’s just not good enough,” he said.
He said a Liberal government would restore move-on laws, scrapped under Daniel Andrews, and introduce protest permits, pointing to NSW, where he said similar measures had significantly reduced the number of “frequent flyer haters”.
“If it was anybody else, there would be stronger laws,” he said.
Southwick also promised to scrap, within 100 days, both payroll tax on private schools, which he said added $1000 to $2000 a year to fees, and the emergency services levy. He pledged to lift the stamp duty threshold for first-home buyers from $700,000 to $1 million.
- Pauline Hanson's One Nation
- Australian Labor Party (ALP)
- Liberal Party of Australia
- Islamic Council of Victoria
- Jewish Community Council of Victoria (JCCV)
- Zionism Victoria
- Beth Weizmann Community Centre
- Victorian Multicultural Commission
- Michael Abelman
- Mikaela Stafrace
- David Southwick
- Malcolm Roberts
- Mohamed Mohideen
- Victorian state election 2026
- Caulfield electorate
- Antisemitism in Victoria
- Bondi Massacre
- Islamophobia
- News
- Australia