Losing Ourselves

Has the West Forgotten What Made It Strong?

Twenty-seven months living in Jerusalem taught me something: what has made Israel strong is precisely what the West has forgotten

A Shabbat table. Photo: Maglara | Dreamstime.com

I grew up in a home where Sunday dinners were sacred. Extended family, a roast in the oven, stories passed across generations, and the comforting sense that you were part of something enduring. That was the Australia I knew as a boy—one with deep roots in tradition, family, and shared values. Today, in our gleaming cities packed with people, it’s astonishing how lonely so many feel. The bonds that once tied us—faith, family, ritual, community—are fraying, and in many places have snapped entirely.

What the Christian West has drifted away from—at great peril—has been preserved for millennia in Judaism. Not just in abstract theology, but in lived ritual: Shabbat dinners that bring families together without screens; holidays that reconnect communities to history and meaning; multi-generational homes that revere wisdom and tradition. These aren’t just customs—they are civilisational pillars. Their erosion hasn’t made us freer. It has made us rootless.

Last Saturday, while visiting a family member in Denver, Colorado, I attended Shabbat services at Aish Shul. I witnessed three or four generations of Jewish families—grandparents, parents, and young children—gathered in worship, song, and warmth amid great turbulence and uncertainty in the wider world. An armed guard stood at the entrance—not to intimidate, but to protect this peaceful, joyful community from the ignorance and barbarism that still lurks outside. Inside, children played without a care in the world. The adults prayed, reflected, and laughed. As an outsider—a non-Jewish Australian Army veteran—I was made to feel completely welcome. The Rabbis spoke with wisdom, humour, and charisma. I left humbled, inspired, and strengthened by the beauty of what I had witnessed.

Even Richard Dawkins—perhaps the world’s most famous atheist—has had cause to reconsider. In a striking public shift, he recently declared himself a “Cultural Christian,” acknowledging that the stories, music, and moral framework of Christianity form the bedrock of Western civilisation. Dawkins, who once dismissed religion as mere superstition, now warns that abandoning Christianity wholesale risks ushering in something far worse. “I prefer the sound of church bells to the call of the muezzin,” he said—not to disparage others, but to defend the civilisational culture we’ve inherited. If even Dawkins sees the danger in losing our moral foundations, should we not ask what else we’re carelessly letting slip?

Since October 7, 2023, when Hamas launched its barbaric assault on Israel, I have watched the West’s reaction with a mixture of despair, disbelief, and—ironically—renewed inspiration. Despair, at the moral confusion displayed by so many in our universities, newsrooms, and streets. Disbelief, at how easily otherwise educated people swallowed Hamas propaganda. But also, inspiration—in the quiet strength, moral clarity, and communal cohesion of Jewish communities around the world.

From July 2019 to September 2021, I lived in Jerusalem while seconded to the United Nations as a senior unarmed peacekeeper. For 27 months, my wife and I had the extraordinary privilege of seeing Israel not as a headline but as a home. We were welcomed into the lives of Jewish, Druze, Christian Arab, and Muslim Arab citizens. I saw what most Western commentators never bother to explore: the complexity, coexistence, and resilience that define the real Israel.

That experience forged bonds that have only deepened since October 7. I count many Jews among my closest friends—some of the most intelligent, hard-working, and decent people I have ever met. I know their values because they are, or once were, ours too: the courage to defend life, the sanctity of truth, the strength of tradition, the love of learning, and the willingness to sacrifice for others.

And yet now we see masked agitators parading through our cities chanting “From the river to the sea”—a genocidal slogan calling for the eradication of the world’s only Jewish state. These aren’t just misguided chants; they are vile, juvenile slogans embraced by cowards and useful idiots. And too many in the West lack the courage—or clarity—to call them out. This is not compassion. It is complicity.

Let me be clear: the attack on Israel was not just an attack on Jews. It was an assault on civilisation itself—on the right to live in peace, the dignity of women, the safety of children, and the fundamental truths that underpin Western liberal democracy. Israel is not perfect, but it is our ally, our mirror, and our warning.

Our warning, because what has made Israel strong is precisely what the West has forgotten. Israel still believes in nationhood. In family. In responsibility. In faith—whether religious or civil. In the truth that freedom comes with duties, not just rights. Meanwhile, too much of the West has sunk into narcissism, nihilism, and performative outrage.

We are being led to the brink by fools—many cloaked in fashionable ideologies and keffiyehs, shouting slogans they barely understand. Their sense of justice is a mile wide and an inch deep. And we—especially our elites—have grown too timid to speak plainly: Hamas are terrorists. Antisemitism is a moral cancer. And the West is still worth defending.

If you want to know what strength looks like, look to the Jewish people. Look at a community that has buried its dead, mourned its murdered children, and still finds time to gather for Shabbat, to sing, to teach, to build. That is not weakness. That is civilisational power.

The West still has time. But not much. We must return to our roots—not in a reactionary or exclusionary way, but with the courage to reclaim the virtues that once sustained us. Traditions matter. Family matters. Truth matters. And unless we are willing to defend them, we will lose them.

We don’t need to become Jews. But we must learn from them.

And if you are a person of goodwill—regardless of faith or background—I encourage you: introduce yourself to the local Jewish community where you live. Get to know the Rabbis. Across my military service, I found that chaplains—our ‘padres’—whether Catholic, Anglican, Jewish or otherwise, were among the kindest, wisest, and most compassionate people in any formation. Their mission was never about proselytising. It was always about service, decency, and care for their fellow man. In an age where so many feel lost, perhaps the answers are simpler, and closer to home, than we care to admit.

Colonel Michael Scott CSC Ret’d is a former Australian army officer and the founder of The 2023 Foundation, an initiative dedicated to combating antisemitism.

read more: