Hormuz to Taiwan: experts warn of risks in two theatres
Jacob Nagel puts a 60 per cent chance on an Iranian pre-emptive strike, while Peter Jennings warns Australia is unprepared for a possible conflict over Taiwan
Iran’s regime may launch a pre-emptive strike rather than face collapse under sustained economic pressure, former head of Israel’s National Security Council Brigadier General (Res.) Professor Jacob Nagel has told the Jerusalem Post Australia Summit.
Speaking on a panel titled “A World in Disorder: Israel, Australia and the Future of Global Security” in Sydney on November 18, Nagel described Iran as “the source for almost every evil and terror support in the world” and said its stated aim of annihilating Israel had to be believed.
He pointed to the countdown clock in Tehran marking the time until 2040, when the regime says Israel will cease to exist. He also cited documents obtained by the Mossad in 2018 showing an order to develop missiles carrying five 10-kiloton nuclear warheads, “five Hiroshimas”.
Despite heavy blows to its nuclear program, missile arsenal, air defences and scientists, Nagel said Iran still held about a third of its missiles. He outlined three scenarios, putting percentages on each.
The first, which he called “the most disturbing”, was a return to negotiations, which he put at 10 to 15 per cent. “If you go with the Iranians to a room to negotiate, you are going to lose anyway,” he said.
The second, which he rated the most likely at 60 per cent, was a pre-emptive strike. He said the regime understood that a situation of “no war and no agreement” would bring about its collapse, and might attack American interests in the Gulf first. “Israel will probably join a war like this,” he said. “We will join if we will be attacked directly, or if the United States will ask us to join.”
The third was that sustained economic pressure from the Trump administration could drive Iranians back onto the streets within six to nine months.
Looking further ahead, Nagel said future wars would be shaped by AI, robotics, hypersonic missiles and swarms of cheap, mass-produced drones, but insisted that “there will be man in the loop” for life-and-death decisions.
Nagel said the world was watching Iran’s leverage over the straits of Hormuz and Bab el-Mandeb closely, drawing a link to Asia. “We have Malacca, we have Taiwan, we have different straits,” he said. “Everyone understands the importance of those straits to the world economy.”
Turning to the Indo-Pacific, and following Nagel’s lead in putting odds on the future, former Australian Strategic Policy Institute executive director Peter Jennings said there was “probably a 50-50 chance that China is going to contemplate military operations against Taiwan sometime between 2027 and 2028”, likely beginning with a blockade.
He said Beijing saw a closing window of opportunity, as China faced demographic and economic pressures while Japan and Taiwan strengthened their militaries. “Inevitably that will draw in Australia,” he said.
With Prime Minister Anthony Albanese due to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping, Jennings said Australia was “kind of a price taker at the moment”.
“Australia is not a country which is thinking strategically about these issues. We don’t have a national security adviser. We don’t have a national security plan,” he said.
Jennings said he agreed with former US National Security Agency director Admiral Michael Rogers, who in an address earlier in the morning warned that growing digital dependency left societies exposed, and that bad actors were applying artificial intelligence more aggressively than defenders.
Rogers, who advised on Australia’s 2023 cyber security strategy, described sitting in a Tel Aviv restaurant when a rocket alert sounded. Diners calmly moved to the centre of the building and returned to their meals seven minutes later. “I’ve never seen a society so resilient,” he said. “That’s an area where I would argue Australia and the United States, we’ve got to get better.”
Jennings said Australia was “not a particularly resilient society, not compared to Israel”, and that only about 1 per cent of defence investment was going into autonomous systems and AI.
“We could learn a lot from Israel in terms of our ability to think more laterally and more quickly, and I deeply regret the fact that our government is not minded to do that right now.”