Jeremy Leibler: ‘The centre does not hold itself’
Outgoing ZFA president Jeremy Leibler used his final address to share three lessons from eight years in the role at the organisation's biennial conference on Sunday
Outgoing Zionist Federation of Australia (ZFA) president Jeremy Leibler has urged the community to “hold the centre” and resist “the temptation of easy answers”, in his final presidential address after eight years in the role.
Leibler was speaking at the ZFA Biennial Conference on November 22, as the organisation approaches its centenary.
Leibler said his tenure had been tested by “a global pandemic, political upheaval in Israel, October the seventh, the wars that followed, an explosion of antisemitism here in Australia, all culminating in Bondi”.
“I don’t think that those experiences, those events, have led me to abandon what I believed in 2018, but they have shown me what it actually means to have those convictions when they are tested in practice,” he said.
Rather than listing achievements, he offered three lessons. The first was to “hold the centre”, which he defined as shared commitments to Jewish peoplehood, to Israel’s existence as a Jewish and democratic state, and to its right to defend itself.
“Holding the centre generally does not mean keeping everyone happy. I found it a fairly lonely place to be over the last eight years,” he said. “Sometimes it means saying things that neither side wants to hear. Sometimes it means challenging people you respect and whose views you otherwise share.
“Israel’s right to defend itself does not place every decision of its government beyond criticism, and criticism of that government does not diminish the legitimacy of Jewish self-determination.”
He said the ZFA had been right to speak out on issues including the extradition of Malka Leifer, judicial reform and “the scourge of settler violence”.
“It would have been far easier to stay silent, to tell ourselves that raising these difficult questions would only provide ammunition to those seeking to demonise Israel, and there are plenty of them waiting in line. But I’m proud that we didn’t,” he said. “There is a difference fundamentally between grappling with Israel’s failings out of a commitment to its future and invoking them to undermine its legitimacy.”
His second lesson was that “defending Jewish life is not the same as living it”. He noted that every Jewish institution now required far greater physical protection than in 2018, but said the purpose of security was “the Jewish life that takes place within”.
“When we see everything through the prism of threat, disagreement can begin to look like disloyalty, and criticism can start to look like hostility,” he said. “It can narrow our Zionism until Israel just becomes primarily a cause to defend, rather than a society that we all need to help build.”
He said he was “in absolute awe of this generation of Israelis” who had defended Israel and the diaspora since October 7.
He pointed to the establishment of the Israel Go program, developed with UIA, Masa and donors as gap-year participation declined, as one of the achievements he was proudest of.
“The purpose of these programmes are not just to equip this next generation to defend Israel,” he said. “We want them to actually have the knowledge, the confidence, and the depth of their own Jewish identity to engage with Israel from their own place of love and commitment, to ask difficult questions without feeling that their identity is threatened.”
His third lesson was that the ZFA “must lead our community and not simply reflect its views”.
Leibler recalled that when he became president, Scott Morrison was prime minister, and “it felt every time I issued a statement began with the words, ‘The ZFA welcomes the Australian government’s decision'”. At the 2020 conference, held online, then shadow foreign minister Penny Wong affirmed Labor’s support for the full IHRA working definition of antisemitism, which the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion has since adopted.
He acknowledged that since Labor came to power, members of the community, including himself, had at times felt “deeply disappointed, angry, and often betrayed”.
“It would have been far easier to respond by declaring our political leaders our enemies and refusing to engage, and amplifying that anger, as some in the community have called on us to do,” he said. “It would have felt very good in the moment, but it would have left us with less influence over the next decision.
“Bipartisanship is easy when both sides say exactly what we want to hear, but it’s tested when they don’t. The relationship between Australia and Israel is too important to become the possession of one side of politics.”
He cautioned against assuming “that everyone who says the right things about Israel is a true friend of the community”, or that everyone who criticises an Israeli government is an enemy.
Recalling the days after October 7, Leibler said his phone rang constantly, often with calls from people he had never met. “What I could actually hear in their voices was fear, real fear,” he said. “They were relying on us.”
He said the community’s effectiveness should be measured by whether it advanced its interests, security and wellbeing, “not by applause from those who already agree with us … not by the number of followers or likes on social media”.
“The centre doesn’t hold itself; people hold it, and for eight years, all of you have,” he said. “Do not mistake the loudest voice for the most effective one.”
He described representing the community as “one of the greatest honours of my life”.