Memorial Day

Only the Dead Have Seen an End to War

Peace is not the natural state of mankind, but a fragile achievement. Remembrance alone is not enough — we must also prepare the living

Headstones of fallen soldiers at Arlington National Cemetery, Virginia. Photo: US Army photo by Spc. James K. McCann/Released, via Wikipedia

“Only the dead have seen the end of war.” These haunting words—frequently misattributed to Plato—were more likely penned by the Spanish-American philosopher George Santayana. Regardless of origin, the sentiment endures: war is not an historical anomaly, but a recurring feature of the human condition. It stalks every era, every civilisation, reminding us that peace is not the natural state of mankind, but a fragile achievement to be defended and preserved.

In the United States, Memorial Day is a solemn occasion set aside to honour those who gave their lives in defence of the nation. It emerged after the American Civil War, formally established in the 1860s, and is now observed on the last Monday of May. Much like Australia’s ANZAC Day, it is a time not for celebration, but for remembrance—marked by wreaths, lowered flags, and quiet acts of reverence.

The men and women we honour did not seek out war. They answered a call—to protect, to serve, and ultimately to sacrifice. It is often said, and rightly so, that no one abhors war more than the soldier. Those of us who have witnessed its horrors understand its cost. And yet we also know that peace is never guaranteed, never permanent, and never secured by good intentions or wishful thinking alone.

We live in a world defined by relentless competition—economic, technological, ideological, and military. This competition does not always escalate into conflict, but history has shown time and again that it often does. Crises can erupt with little warning, and the illusion of enduring peace can disappear in an instant. It is a dangerous delusion to believe that peace can be achieved simply by desiring it. Peace, when real, is defended—and never defined by the goodwill of our adversaries.

Our obligation is to protect our families, our values, our freedoms, and our way of life. This duty demands more than military might—it requires vigilance, moral clarity, and civic resolve. Yet across much of the West, a troubling complacency has taken hold. Our societies, enriched and secure for generations, now seem unsure of themselves. Strategic foresight has faded. Military readiness has been allowed to erode. The virtues of sacrifice and service are too often met with cynicism or ridicule. While we debate pronouns and police microaggressions, our adversaries prepare for war.

Consider China. For decades, the Chinese Communist Party has pursued a methodical, strategic campaign to reshape the global order in its image. In The Long Game, Rush Doshi outlines how Beijing has sought to undermine U.S. influence and assert Chinese dominance across military, economic, technological, and diplomatic spheres. China’s military modernisation is not accidental—it is coherent, disciplined, and driven by a worldview that sees the West as a declining rival.

Russia, for its part, has transformed its economy into a war engine. According to multiple Western intelligence assessments, Moscow has been mobilising its industrial base for armed conflict for over two years. The invasion of Ukraine was not a miscalculation—it was an expression of a long-standing ambition to reassert Russian power and dismantle the post-Cold War European security order. Vladimir Putin has actively cultivated alliances with other authoritarian regimes, effectively forging a new axis of autocracy.

Russia, China, Iran, and North Korea are now operating in increasing alignment. Through arms transfers, intelligence sharing, technological cooperation, and coordinated diplomacy, these regimes act with mutual purpose. Iran supplies drones to Russia. North Korea provides munitions and manpower. China offers diplomatic protection. Together, their apparent aim is to erode Western power and dismantle the liberal international order.

This is the world in 2025 as it exists—not as we wish it to be. We may not want war. We may not feel ready for it. But that does not matter. As American historian Robert Kagan once warned, “You may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.” That interest may come through cyberattacks, supply chain sabotage, border provocations, or acts of terrorism. It may come gradually—or all at once. Either way, we must be prepared.

At times it feels as though many in the West are blind to this truth. There is a growing chorus of negativity directed at the United States, Israel, and other democracies—as if our own imperfections justify the malevolence of those who seek our downfall. Hostile regimes seem content to watch the postmodern West eat itself from within, fanning the flames of cultural self-loathing through misinformation and manipulation.

This Memorial Day, I reflect on the great operational fear that haunted me during my years commanding Australian soldiers in war: that complacency—and the shortcuts it breeds—can be our greatest threat. War punishes the unready. And too often, the cost is paid in the lives of the best among us.

Have we become complacent? Have we reduced Memorial Day to a day off work, rather than a solemn occasion to pause, reflect, and remember those who died to secure the freedoms we now take for granted?

Human history tends to move in waves—sinusoidal cycles of strength and decline, sacrifice and indulgence. In Australia, there was a time when the commemoration of ANZAC Day waned. But in recent decades, we’ve seen a resurgence—led, inspiringly, by young Australians who understand the power of remembrance. We must ensure Memorial Day follows a similar path.

Because remembrance is not enough.

On Memorial Day, we honour the dead. But we must also prepare the living. The freedoms we cherish—freedom to speak, to worship, to dissent—are not historical guarantees. They are victories, won by generations past and preserved only through vigilance and resolve.

Let us remember them not only with gratitude, but with action. For only the dead have seen the end of war—and the living must carry the burden of preventing its return.

Colonel Michael Scott CSC Ret’d is a former Australian army officer and the founder of The 2023 Foundation, an initiative dedicated to combating antisemitism.

read more: