Zionist debate

Regev: Canberra’s two-state focus ‘just virtue signalling’

At the ZFA Biennial Conference, Mark Regev urges Australia to help bring Indonesia into the Abraham Accords, as Einat Wilf argues the two-state solution ‘never lived’

Mark Regev at the ZFA Biennial Conference.

Former Israeli government spokesman Mark Regev has said the Australian government’s focus on a two-state solution is “just virtue signalling”, urging Canberra to instead use its influence to help bring Indonesia into the circle of peace with Israel.

Speaking on a panel at the Zionist Federation of Australia (ZFA) Biennial Conference on November 22, Regev said there would not be peace between Israelis and Palestinians “any time soon”, and that leaders who wanted to advance peace in the Middle East needed to prioritise what was achievable.

“If you try to do everything, you do nothing,” said Regev, a former Israeli ambassador to the United Kingdom and a graduate of Habonim in Australia.

“Everyone who … talks about two-state solution, two-state solution, like the government here in Canberra, yes, the Australian government … It’s not going to happen. It’s just virtue signalling. It’s just talk. It’s just empty words of no political importance whatsoever.”

Instead, he said, those who wanted peace should support the expansion of the Abraham Accords. With US President Donald Trump having two years left in office and having lost control of Congress and hence his ability to pursue a domestic agenda, Regev said deals between Israel and Lebanon or Saudi Arabia were “not impossible”, as was a security agreement with Syria.

“We could get a peace agreement normalisation with the largest Muslim majority country on the planet, which is a neighbour of Australia, Indonesia,” he said, noting that Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto had said “Shalom” in his address to the United Nations last year.

“If I was meeting with [Foreign Minister] Penny Wong, I would say to her, Australia has special influence on Indonesia. Australia can actually, maybe working side by side with the Americans, lead to a breakthrough between the Jewish state and the largest Muslim majority country on the planet.”

“Is Australia helping to do that by focusing only on a two-state solution? The answer is no,” he said.

Former Knesset member Einat Wilf argued that the two-state solution had never been viable at all. “Nothing has made the two-state solution no longer viable because it was never alive,” she said. “There’s nothing that killed it because it never lived.”

Wilf said that in the past century, there had “not been a single moment when there was an Arab and especially a Palestinian Arab vision of peace where one of the two states is the Jewish state”. She urged anyone who heard Palestinian leaders endorse two states to ask a follow-up question: whether one of the two would be the Jewish state, and whether Palestinians would give up the claimed “right of return”.

“What you will find is that they will always say, ‘Oh no, refugees return. That’s sacred,'” she said. “That means that the only two-state solution they ever envisioned was an Arab state in the West Bank and Gaza and another Arab state to replace Israel.”

From left: Michael Borsky, Einat Wilf, Mark Regev and Nirit Eylon.

Regev dismissed the narrative that Israeli democracy was in crisis as “a bunch of baloney”, pointing to the 1948 Altalena affair, violent protests over German reparations in the 1950s and the 1995 assassination of prime minister Yitzhak Rabin.

“People look back at the good old days, when Israeli democracy was strong and Israelis were less polarised. It’s rubbish. Israelis always argued,” he said. “Israeli democracy has challenges … but the idea that the democracy itself is under threat, I don’t believe that to be true, not at all.”

On a second question, whether Zionism had fulfilled its purpose, Regev said the answer was “clearly no”. “We’ve seen, especially in this city, the rebirth and the energisation of antisemitism,” he said. “There was a time when antisemitism was unfashionable … Today, it’s very fashionable to be antisemitic.

“But something very important has changed. The Jewish people have changed … We’re no longer stateless, homeless, defenceless. We can actually fight back.”

Wilf said Zionism as a political movement had “achieved its goal and spectacularly so”, but that today it served another purpose. She described what she called the “pound of flesh” dynamic, in which Jews in progressive circles were expected to renounce part of their identity as the price of acceptance.

“It used to be enough to say that you’re against Bibi or that you’re for a two-state solution, but then it moved. You had to say that Zionism is racism, that Israel is an apartheid. Now nothing less than genocide will get you through the door,” she said. “Bullying preys on shame … Zionism has just become a shorthand to tell to the bullies, go away. There’s nothing to find here.”

Tech entrepreneur Nirit Eylon, an Israeli who has lived in Australia for many years, offered a counterpoint. “You cannot call yourself a democratic country and rule the life of four million people without rights,” she said, adding that Israel’s neighbours were waiting to see what happened with the Palestinians before signing new agreements.

Eylon, who grew up in Jerusalem during the intifada, said military success had to be translated into a diplomatic achievement, though not necessarily a two-state solution. “If you don’t translate those amazing acts into some diplomatic solution … hope will not be built,” she said. “Living through war only brings despair.”

The panel was moderated by former ZFA board member Michael Borsky.

read more: