SPOTLIGHT ON SBS PODCAST

SBS news reporter breached editorial standards

SBS's Essam Al-Ghalib cleared of deliberate bias in relation to errors in podcast about Hebron incident.

SBS World News reporter Essam Al-Ghalib was temporarily stood down, but later returned to full duties following Ombudman's inquiry clearing him of any deliberate bias. Photo: Youtube Screenshot.

An SBS world news cross platform reporter who had posted anti-Israel comments and false claims on social media – and used the hashtag #F**kIsrael – in a previous job almost a decade earlier when working in public relations in Saudi Arabia, was temporarily suspended after errors were found in his January 31, 2022 podcast report into an incident in Hebron.

On Monday, an SBS spokesperson confirmed to The AJN that Essam Al-Ghalib is a cross-platform journalist employed on a casual basis with SBS, and action has now been taken in regard to this matter.

“In light of some tweets published between 2014 and 2015, which we’ve become aware of, he [Al-Ghalib] has been stood down from all duties, pending an internal investigation,” the SBS spokesperson said.

Earlier, on February 1, media monitoring website Honest Reporting exposed a series of Al-Ghalib’s tweets he made between 2014 and 2015, including one which said, “A f**king Israeli soldier choking a Palestinian boy”.

Other tweets by Al-Ghalib in that period claimed that Israel put Palestinians in “concentration camps”, that Israeli soldiers are “bloody murderers”, and that Israel is “the biggest terrorist in the world”.

Honest Reporting claimed when they contacted Al-Ghalib last week, he told them that at the time he posted those tweets, that he was employed as a public relations staff member at Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Culture and Information, before beginning his journalism career.

Honest Reporting also claimed that when they published a tweet on February 1, 2023 that first exposed Al-Ghalib’s anti-Israel tweets, he “swifly moved to delete his posts”.

Al-Ghalib’s most recent report for SBS News about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was a podcast on January 31, 2022, in which he reported that the Palestinian Health Ministry said Israeli forces killed a Palestinian man, Nayef Salman Abu Fouda, by shooting him in the head in Hebron.

That report was described as biased by Honest Reporting, for failing to mention that Abu Fouda had attempted to carry out a terrorist attack by ramming his vehicle into a group of Israeli soldiers.

Commenting on the matter, Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council executive director Colin Rubenstein said, “It is a duty of journalists to provide objective, balanced and fair reports.

“We hope SBS will ensure Al-Ghalib maintains the organisation’s high standards of reporting.

“We very much welcome this appropriate decision by SBS to investigate this matter.”

UPDATE

In her determination of February 20, 2023, SBS Ombudsman Amy Stockwell found that the Israeli military’s perspective had not been deliberately omitted in Al-Ghalib’s podcast of January 31, 2022.

Stockwell did find that the resulting delay in presenting the IDF’s perspective in that podcast did breach SBS’s editorial standards, but was likely a scripting error rather than deliberate exclusion.

Two wire reports describing the same incident in Hebron had been mistaken for separate events – an error that also escaped the editor who reviewed Al-Ghalib’s script for the podcast.

Stockwell concluded that the podcast was otherwise balanced.

That podcast was subsequently removed by SBS, but the Ombudsman’s findings did not establish deliberate bias, professional dishonesty, or antisemitism.

According to Al-Ghalib himself, the SBS investigation was launched after he voluntarily disclosed the offending tweets he posted during his time in Saudi Arabia.

Al-Ghalib returned to work at SBS News, including reporting on Israel and the Middle East.

read more: