Echoes of Vietnam

The demonisation of soldiers then and now

The burden of narrative is not the soldier’s to bear. It falls to the rest of us — those who live in safety and enjoy the freedoms they protect

Australians arrive at Tan Son Nhut Airport, Saigon. Photo: US military personnel / Wikimedia Commons

It is hard to think of a more shameful moment in Australian history—perhaps save the one we are living through today—than the vile reception afforded to many of our Vietnam veterans. Australia deployed nearly 60,000 servicemen and women to Vietnam between 1962 and 1975. They served with courage, honour, and professionalism. But on their return home, they were met not with gratitude, but with disgrace.

They did not start that war. They did not choose their deployment. They went because their government sent them—because duty called. And yet, on their return to Australia, many were spat on, jeered at, and labelled “baby killers.” These scenes were repeated in other Western capitals then, as we see again today—to our great societal shame.

One Australian Vietnam veteran, Denny Whitmeyer, recalled: “I changed my military clothes on an airplane into civilian clothes because there was [sic] problems in the airports.” Another remembered protesters hurling abuse and animal blood. These weren’t fringe outbursts. They were part of a broader cultural sickness—a readiness to scapegoat those who bore the burden of service.

Today, a new generation of soldiers faces an eerily similar campaign of vilification.

This time, it’s the young men and women of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). They too did not choose this war. They too were called to serve. Many were roused from their beds on October 7th as Hamas terrorists launched the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust. Entire families were butchered. Babies burned. Holocaust survivors abducted.

As Rudyard Kipling observed in his poem Tommy, written more than a century ago:

“It’s Tommy this, an’ Tommy that, an’ ‘Chuck him out, the brute!’ But it’s ‘Saviour of ‘is country’ when the guns begin to shoot.”

And yet, in the days and weeks that followed, it was not the perpetrators who faced condemnation, but those who defended their people. The blood libel has returned—repackaged for the digital age.

Across the West, IDF soldiers have been branded “genocidal,” “monsters,” “war criminals.” At Columbia University, Professor Joseph Massad referred to the October 7 attack as “awesome” and a “stunning victory of the Palestinian resistance.” Social media teems with invective. Posters of kidnapped children are ripped down. On July 4, 2025, masked protesters stormed Miznon, an Israeli-owned restaurant in Melbourne, chanting “Death to the IDF” and damaging property. That same night, a man set fire to the front door of the East Melbourne Hebrew Congregation while 20 worshippers were gathered for Shabbat. It was a deliberate act of arson—domestic terrorism. Thankfully, no lives were lost. The alleged perpetrator was arrested and charged the following evening. These were not isolated acts of vandalism. They were premeditated attacks on Jewish life. Just days earlier, the stage at Glastonbury had hosted an abominable rapper whose lyrics trafficked in rage, not reason. This is not protest. It is hate.

Let the law respond with appropriate weight. Not just for justice, but for deterrence. Sentencing principles exist not only to punish but to uphold societal standards. That matters here.

Because there is a troubling passivity to modern antisemitism. It rarely marches in black boots anymore. It hides behind “human rights” slogans. It chants “ceasefire” with one hand and posts glorification of Hamas with the other. It dehumanises Israelis and then feigns surprise when Jews are attacked on city streets.

Let us be clear: mistakes happen in war. They happen in every war. And wherever there is a collective of humans, some will fail to uphold the high standard expected of them. That is true in every army. It was true in Vietnam and in Afghanistan. But these instances are the exception, not the rule.

It is my professional judgment that the IDF is the most lawful, ethical, and restrained fighting force in human history. I say this with the experience of commanding Australian combat soldiers on operations in East Timor (1999) and Afghanistan (2011)—being well-versed in the application of rules of engagement, orders for opening fire, and the laws of war. I was also briefed in detail by Israel’s Military Advocate General’s Corps (MAG Corps) in September 2024, when I returned to Israel as part of a senior veteran delegation named the Military Expert Panel.

General Sir John McColl (Ret’d), former Deputy Supreme Allied Commander at NATO, who was on my trip, remarked to the press after returning: “The operational procedures the IDF have, in terms of the law of armed conflict, are as strong as ours [UK Armed Forces].” He added, “I went there sceptical,” but concluded that the IDF are doing “their absolute level best” to minimise casualties.

What the IDF is doing exceeds the standards other Western militaries achieved in the past two decades—in Iraq and Afghanistan—by a factor. There is a stark contrast between the ethical conduct of the IDF in Gaza and the barbarism of Russian forces in Ukraine, or the brutality of the Syrian regimes—past and current—which goes largely unreported by our partisan and manipulative media.

The IDF conducts internal investigations. It cancels missions to avoid civilian harm. It telegraphs operations in ways no other military on Earth does. No other democracy has ever faced the genocidal threat Israel does—with terrorists hiding behind human shields—and responded with such moral restraint.

To the mothers and fathers of IDF soldiers in Israel and across the Diaspora, I say this: be incredibly proud. Your sons and daughters have not lost their morality. They are guardians. They have stood, lion-hearted, when not only Israel, but the entire civilised world needed them. In time, they will grow to be the best of us.

War is not something any civilised society wishes upon its children. The Vietnamese novelist and veteran Bao Ninh, in The Sorrow of War (1993, Secker & Warburg), wrote a haunting line:

“My life seems little different from that of a sampan pushed upstream towards the past. The future lied to us, there long ago in the past. There is no new life, no new era, nor is it hope for a beautiful future that now drives me on, but rather the opposite. The hope is contained in the beautiful pre-war past.”

Elsewhere, he observes:

“The sorrow of war inside a soldier’s heart is in a strange way similar to the sorrow of love. It is a kind of nostalgia, a deep, endless sadness.”

That is the soldier’s burden. The sights. The sounds. The smells. The memories. The silent grief that will accompany them long after the shooting stops. But the burden of narrative—of explanation and oratory and moral defence—is not theirs to bear. That burden falls to the rest of us: the citizens of decent society.

We cannot leave them alone on the battlefield of ideas. It is for those of us who live in safety, who enjoy the freedoms they protect, to confront the radicals in our midst—those who delude themselves that their protestations are noble while glorifying Hamas, denying Jewish pain, and pretending that antisemitism is just another form of political discourse.

For the rest of us who do not bear the burden of the soldier nor carry a gun, I will leave you with the insightful words of Israeli influencer Yon Gruber—someone I do not know personally, but who has captured the mood of many of my friends in Israel and across the world. On 16 June 2025, he posted:

“This is an important reminder to the world. I am speaking on behalf of 100% of Israelis, from the far left to the extreme right. Our goal is to live in our country and chill. No worries. We have no problem with the existence of Iran, Syria, Lebanon. We don’t even have a problem with the Palestinians in Gaza. No. The problem only starts when someone wants to wipe us out. Because it clashes with our desire to live. Sure, we have a land dispute with the Palestinians. But we are great at resolving disputes. We are a nation of lawyers. We know how to settle sh*t. No problem. But when you want to kill us and you say it out loud like a total lunatic, it’s a bit difficult to have a conversation. And I won’t lie to you guys. All these wars, it’s exhausting and depressing. We hate it. I just want to watch the NBA Finals. That’s it. But we have no choice. Have a nice, missile-free day. And bring our hostages back, please.”

His words encapsulate the truth that too many in the West refuse to see. Israel is not fighting to conquer. It is fighting to survive.

To pretend otherwise is not just morally wrong—it is dangerous. It emboldens terrorists. It betrays our values. And it demoralises those who risk everything for us.

In 2024 and 2025, we face a moment not unlike the 1970s. A clash between truth and propaganda. Between courage and cowardice. Between duty and derision. This time, let us not repeat the same shameful mistakes. Let us not abandon those who stand on the wall.

Israel is a frontier democracy. That reality seems to have flown blissfully over the heads of many in Australian society. But make no mistake—the IDF is not only defending Israel. In confronting Hamas in Gaza and the genocidal ayatollahs in Tehran, they are defending the values, freedoms, and way of life that underpin all liberal democracies, including our own.

As German Chancellor Friedrich Merz recently put it: “Israel is doing the dirty work for all of us.”

If we do not speak out, who will?

If we do not act now, when?

To the men and women of the IDF—and to all those who serve with moral clarity in the fog of war—thank you. You carry more than a rifle. You carry the burden of civilisation.

Am Yisrael Chai.

Michael Scott CSC is the CEO and Founder of The 2023 Foundation, a charity focused on combating antisemitism through lived experience. He previously served for thirty years in the Australian Army, rising to the rank of colonel. The views expressed are his own and do not reflect the official positions of the Australian Defence Force or the Commonwealth Government of Australia.

read more: