Unmatched Restraint

The Israeli government, IDF, and the moral burden of war

What other nation drops leaflets, makes phone calls and sends texts to enemy civilians, knowing it costs the element of surprise and risks its own soldiers?

An IDF map of the civilian evacuation of Rafah ahead of a planned offensive, released May 6, 2024. Image: Israel Defence Forces)

In the theatre of modern warfare, there are few examples of military restraint as profound as that demonstrated by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the Israeli Government since the atrocities of October 7, 2023. As the world watches, often through a distorting lens of misinformation and moral relativism, it is imperative to state plainly what too many refuse to admit: no Western military has ever been held to the impossible standard that Israel now meets, every single day.

The scale of the October 7 attack was grotesque in both intent and execution. Civilians were butchered, babies burned alive, women raped, families slaughtered, and hostages taken—including young Kfir Bibas and his brother Ariel, along with their mother Shiri. The recent return of their bodies to Israel, alongside the still-grieving Eli Sharabi—whose wife and daughters were also murdered by Hamas—should sear the conscience of any who claim to care about justice or humanity. These families weren’t “collateral damage.” They were the targets.

Yet even in the face of such horror, Israel has exercised extraordinary discipline in the conduct of its military operations. The IDF issues advance warnings before strikes. It allows humanitarian corridors. It pauses offensives to permit aid and evacuations. What other nation on Earth would drop leaflets, make phone calls, and send text messages to enemy civilians, urging them to seek shelter—knowing full well that doing so may cost the element of surprise and risk the lives of its own soldiers?

Compare this with the open declarations of genocidal intent from Hamas and even the Palestinian Authority. Consider Ghazi Hamad, a senior Hamas official, who publicly vowed that “October 7 was just the first time,” and that it will be “repeated again and again.” Or the chilling statement by Mahmoud al-Zahar, another senior Hamas leader: “Israel must be erased.” These are not the words of misunderstood militants. They are the language of extermination. They make no distinction between soldier and civilian, Jew and gentile, adult and child.

Meanwhile, voices from the Palestinian Authority offer little in the way of moderation. PA President Mahmoud Abbas has a long and troubling record of Holocaust minimisation, having claimed in a 1983 dissertation that Zionists collaborated with Nazis. More recently, PA representatives have refused to condemn the October 7 massacre, instead continuing to glorify “martyrs” and incentivise terror through the notorious “pay-for-slay” program.

It is within this environment—a culture that venerates death, dehumanises Jews, and distorts truth—that Israel is fighting for its survival. And yet, Israel fights not as its enemies do. The restraint is not only tactical, but moral.

Critics, often sitting comfortably in the safety of Western capitals, cry “disproportionate response” from behind keyboards. But they forget history—or ignore it. After 9/11, the United States launched a global war on terror that included airstrikes, drone campaigns, and the decapitation of entire terrorist networks. The NATO-led invasion of Afghanistan toppled a regime within weeks. The British, in the 19th century, waged a campaign of retribution after the First Anglo-Afghan War that saw Kabul burned and retribution meted out with ruthless precision.

And during World War II, Allied forces firebombed Dresden and Tokyo, reducing entire cities to rubble. Civilians died in the tens of thousands. These were not war crimes—they were wartime decisions made under the moral calculus of defeating evil. Victory sometimes demands ferocity. Yet Israel, even when justified by any historical standard, chooses restraint.

This restraint is not a sign of weakness. It reflects the values Israel was built upon. The IDF is not only a fighting force—it is the moral spine of a democratic nation. Its commanders make impossible decisions in impossible circumstances. And they do so with one hand tied behind their back by the international community, while the other shields their civilians from slaughter and their soldiers from moral corruption.

The double standard is deafening. No other army is expected to win a war against terrorists embedded within civilian populations while facing global condemnation for defending its own people. No other democracy would tolerate thousands of rockets raining down upon its cities before acting. And no other people, having endured a pogrom on live television, would be scolded for daring to defend themselves.

Yet Israel does. With courage, clarity, and a conscience.

Golda Meir once said, “A bad headline is better than a good eulogy.” In today’s media climate, Israel has endured plenty of bad headlines. But thanks to the restraint and resolve of its leaders and soldiers, far fewer eulogies than its enemies intended.

Colonel Michael Scott CSC Ret’d is a former Australian army officer and the founder of The 2023 Foundation, an initiative dedicated to combating antisemitism.

read more: