The Victorian Greens’ obsession with Israel
The Victorian Greens’ stance on Israel deserves closer scrutiny as Victoria heads to the polls on November 28.
So much of the focus ahead of this Victorian election has been on the more than 20 per cent of Victorian voters intending to vote for One Nation, according to recent polling. But published polls are also showing that around one in six Victorian voters intend to vote for the Greens.
While One Nation has only ever had one elected representative from Victoria, current Upper House MP Rikkie-Lee Tyrrell, the Greens have been active in Victorian Parliament for more than a decade. This means that they are not a mystery. The views of Victorian Greens are well known, and to be frank, they are alarming to the majority of local Jewish voters.
In addition, if the local Greens follow the trajectory of their global counterparts, the future does not look bright for those of us who believe in a Jewish state in Israel and safety and fairness for all, including the local Jewish community.
The Victorian Greens, led on this issue by Richmond MP Gabrielle de Vietri, have made Israel a rallying cry. They have focused on the terrible conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, more than some domestic policy issues, despite state governments having no jurisdiction over foreign affairs.
De Vietri, in her first statement to Parliament on the issue after October 7, 2023, did not mention a single Israeli casualty, not a single hostage and issued no condemnation of Hamas.
The Victorian Greens obsession runs wide and deep. It has included stunts in Parliament – for which Greens MPs have faced sanctions – wearing large keffiyehs into the chamber and holding signs reading “Vic Labor stop arming Israel” during parliamentary debates.
During the most recently concluded term of Parliament, the Greens mentioned Israel in 122 speeches, including a last gasp on the final day of this Victorian Parliament. In that speech, De Vietri accused Labor of supporting genocide, of grovelling “at Netanyahu’s feet” and finished with the threat “history will remember you”.
The Australian reported that during 2024, the Victorian Greens tried 52 times to move motions against Israel. All of this brings to mind the famous line from the classic 2004 movie, Mean Girls: “Why are you so obsessed with me?”
Away from Parliament, De Vietri has spoken out the front of divisive pro-Palestine protests on multiple occasions, including standing alongside known extremists and alleged criminals.
Her colleague, and the Greens Spokesperson for Multicultural Affairs, Anasina Gray-Barberio proudly joined protests against the February 2026 visit by Israel’s President Isaac Herzog.
The visit, by a widely respected head of state, was to show solidarity with the victims of the Bondi Beach terrorist attack. Gray-Barberio falsely told Parliament that Herzog was “found to be inciting genocide by the International Court of Justice”, with her colleague, De Vietri, branding him a “war criminal” and calling on Australia to arrest him under the Geneva Convention.
If the Victorian Greens had their way, Australia would cut all diplomatic and commercial ties with Israel.
It is true that the Greens used to appeal to some Jewish voters. A small but active group existed, called the Jewish Greens Network. At last state election, the Greens fielded a Jewish candidate in the seat of Caulfield and the late David Zyngier represented the Greens as a local councillor until his untimely passing in late 2023.
However as Dr Philip Mendes, an academic and expert on local progressive Jewish politics, wrote in an article for The Times of Israel, “Following the October 2023 Hamas massacre, the Australian Greens quickly pivoted to a uniformly antizionist fundamentalist position, and shortly afterwards to an institutionally antisemitic perspective.” The Jewish Greens Network dissolved during this time.
Even if the Greens’ vote does not grow as polling is predicting, the party is highly likely to remain a presence in the Victorian Parliament. In that case, we must work to ensure the local Greens do not follow their UK counterparts in ludicrously declaring “Zionism is racism” and calling for a “single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital”.
These newly adopted policies have caused even deeper divisions in the UK and left an already shaky Jewish community, which has dealt with deadly synagogue attacks and its own horrific arsons, once again reeling. At a national level, the Greens have crossed lines, most recently when Senator Nick McKim said in Parliament that the Australian government had been “captured by Zionist interests”, presenting Zionism as a nefarious or dark force.
Our democracy is best served by MPs who seek to listen, to bring people together and to focus on issues they can control. While much of the public focus has been on One Nation ahead of polling day on November 28, we cannot overlook the other minor party, the Greens, aggressively seeking votes this election.
Naomi Levin is CEO of the Jewish Community Council of Victoria (JCCV).