Defining the Jewish story It is time to stop asking permission to exist

Time to move from defending to defining

Jewish communities must shape their own agenda in the fight against antisemitism and make the case for Israel.

The Oslo Accords. Israeli PM Yitzhak Rabin shakes PA President Yasser Arafat's hand as US President Bill Clinton looks on. Israel's concessions were met with terror.

Eleven months ago, on a summer evening at Bondi Beach, Jewish families gathered to light the first Chanukah candle. Gunmen opened fire, and 15 people were murdered. Two years earlier came October 7.

In between, what did we do? We counted incidents. We issued statements. We reported posts and asked governments to protect us.

The people who did that work are heroes. But it is time to say something uncomfortable. For decades we have played defence on a field drawn by others, under rules written by others. Defence alone has never won anything.

For 80 years we lived inside an order built by America and its allies after 1945, an order that rebuilt the defeated rather than crushing them. That order is ending. In 2024 the world recorded 61 state-based armed conflicts, the most since 1946. We are entering a multipolar world of ad-hoc coalitions.

Israel is a rising power in technology, defence and resilience. The fight over its legitimacy is not a side story. It is one front in a contest over which values will organise the next world order.

Freedom is not humanity’s natural state. We are free because Australians, Americans and Britons fought for it. If we will not defend it, it will be taken from us.

At the core of what we face is what many call the Red-Green alliance. Extreme progressive ideology is on one side and Islamism on the other, and both are amplified by states seeking to weaken Western societies from within. For these actors, Israel is not a border dispute to be settled. It is one front among many.

Millions of Muslims are kind, law-abiding people who want to live in peace. That is not the question. The question is which ideology drives the movements trying to reshape our societies. Islamism is a political ideology with imperial ambitions, and appeasement has never satisfied it.

Islamism exploits the openness and self-restraint of liberal democracy. The 20th century’s answer was the defensive democracy: a free society that refuses to let tolerance become a weapon against itself.

The alliance is also riddled with contradiction. Gay rights activists march for movements that execute gay people. Feminist organisations fell silent about the sexual violence of October 7. Exposing that hypocrisy to people who are simply uninformed is our opportunity.

We are told Israel refuses peace. At Oslo in 1993, Israel recognised the PLO and handed over territory, and the answer was buses blown up in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. In 1994, Arafat told a Johannesburg mosque that Oslo was a temporary truce, like the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah. At Camp David in 2000, Israel offered a state, and the answer was the Second Intifada. In 2005, every Jew left Gaza. A year later Gazans elected Hamas, and there has been no election since. Then came the rockets, and October 7.

Look, too, at what is taught: payments to terrorists scaled to the length of their sentences, schoolbooks glorifying “martyrs”, and summer camps training children for combat. And look at the map. At its narrowest, Israel is about 15km wide, overlooked by the hills of Judea and Samaria.

As Israelis say: if they lay down their weapons, there will be peace; if we lay down ours, there will be no Israel. The burden of proof is on them.

Much of our communal effort has been built around hate speech: monitor it, report it, condemn it, ask for its removal. That work is necessary, but as a strategy it has three flaws. It is reactive, so the other side sets the agenda. It is fought on their ground: we argue about what may be said, while they argue about what is true and just. And it casts us as victims seeking protection from institutions that have often already been captured.

Israel’s own effort has fared no better. Israel has spent heavily on public diplomacy since October 2023, yet Gallup found only nine per cent of Americans aged 18 to 34 approved of the Gaza campaign. The deeper problem is that there is no strategy. There is no single owner, no audience segmentation, no testing and no measurement. Thousands of committed people, and no plan.

We must move from reactive to proactive, from defending to defining, from victims to bearers of a story. We stop waiting for the next accusation and set the narrative ourselves: who we are, what we stand for, and why it matters to every free society.

Our Jewish heritage is our backbone, the quarry from which we draw unity, hope and identity. Our story can return hope to a Western culture that has lost faith in itself.

Countering extremist recruitment online is essential, but recruitment is the symptom. The cause is the ideology behind it. Treat the symptom and ignore the cause, and we will be here again next year.

History shows that concessions, silence and the fear of drawing clear lines do not reduce hatred. They encourage it. We have to stand up in the media, in politics, in the courts and in the public square. If we don’t, the societies that protected us for generations may no longer be able to.

This is not only about Israel. It is about whether the free world still recognises the ideologies that seek to replace it, and still has the will to defend itself.

It is time to stop asking permission to exist. Stop defending. Start defining.

Ayal Marek is president of ARZA Australia.

read more: