The eighth front

Zionism is for builders, not blamers, says Einat Wilf

Former Knesset member Einat Wilf and ARZA Australia’s Ayal Marek told the Jerusalem Post Australia Summit how to win the battle for Israel’s legitimacy

EInat Wilf and Ayal Marek.

Zionism is “the attitude of people who have come to build”, former Knesset member Einat Wilf has told the Jerusalem Post Australia Summit, urging supporters to draw a clear line between “builders and destroyers”.

Speaking on a panel titled “The Eighth Front” in Sydney on November 18, Wilf said the task of winning over the next generation began with that distinction.

“Zionism is compelling,” she said. “Zionism is the ideology, is the attitude of people who have come to build, people who have seen a malarial land and say we can make something of this … people who, in the face of trauma and difficulties, create, build, innovate.

“Zionism is ultimately the attitude of people who look at the adversity of life and say, ‘I’ll deal with it. I’ll assume responsibility. I’ll make something of it.'”

Its opposite, she said, was the ideology of “whiners” – “people who, as they look at life, all they can do is blame others for their failures”.

“People whose attitude to life is to blame everyone else will always go for antizionism as a way to explain why everyone is responsible but them,” she said. “We need to appeal in every culture – Arabs and Muslims and Western culture and everywhere – to those people whose human attitude to life is to build, to create, and that’s Zionism.”

Asked how to confront antizionism now that it had entered the mainstream, Wilf said Jews needed to respond in two parallel ways. The first was to “prepare for some extreme possibilities”, because Jews had historically suffered from “a timing problem”.

“By the time that the rest of the world wakes up to the disaster that the ideological insanity is, Jews have often suffered the brunt of the damage,” she said. “This is a time to take care of our own in whichever way you see fit.”

The second was to find and equip non-Jewish allies.

“Everywhere that antizionism rose to become an institutionalised ideology, Jews were gone,” she said, citing the Arab world, Iran, the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. “If you were to understand that this is a fact, would you be horrified or not? This is how you know who our allies are.

“We need non-Jews to realise that antizionism, like antisemitism before it, is the ideology of failed and failing societies.”

Fellow panellist Ayal Marek, president of ARZA Australia, said the pro-Israel community was “playing defence … on a field that was determined by others”.

“We have to move from defending to defining, from being reactive to setting the narrative,” he said.

Marek said that meant using trusted messengers within communities, “not paid influencers necessarily, that backfires once it’s exposed”, responding quickly before false narratives took hold, and tailoring messages to different audiences: human rights for progressives, sovereignty and liberal democracy for conservatives.

“What we’re lacking, in my opinion, and research confirms that, is strategy and coordination,” he said.

He said Zionism should be defined affirmatively as the right of the Jewish people, “as the indigenous people”, to sovereignty in their ancestral land. “If everybody else is entitled to it, why do you exclude us specifically?” he said. “If they deny it, the burden is on them.”

The panel was moderated by The Jerusalem Post’s Anna Ahronheim.

read more: